| Name | Rating in Log | My Rating | Where? | Notes |
| Pabst Blue Ribbon Beer | 50 | 30 | in cans at the VF | "I've got a taste for livin'. I'm drinkin cold Blue Ribbon. I got Pabst Blue Ribbon on my mind." Not bad, but it gave me a headache. |
| Papago Churchill Wheat Wine | | 60 | beer #105 at 2001 GABF | Scottsdale, AZ |
| Paper City Indian Pale Ale | | 70 | beer #49 at 2001 GABF | Holyoke, MA |
| Paper City Riley's Irish Stout | | 75 | beer #160 at 2001 GABF | |
| Park City Steamer | | 50 | beer #1 at 2001 GABF | Herber City, UT |
| Pater Lieven Bruin | Not Listed | 85 | tasted on tap at Sudds (9/13/00) | very sweet, strong, wine-like belgian brown which lingers long and is welcomed |
| Paulaner Hefe-Weizen | 43 | 65 | Variety Brews, Dunmore | |
| Paulaner Oktoberfest Marzen | | 55 | Variety Brews, Scranton | another one Keda picked out |
| Paulaner Salvator Double Bock | 94 | 95 | Variety Brews, Moosic | Probably my favorite so far. Very close to a perfect beer. Started out amazing, but weakened just a bit as I went on. |
| Pelican Indian Pelican Ale | | 70 | beer #34 at 2001 GABF | Pacific City, OR |
| Pendle Witches Brew | | 55 | Variety Brews, Dunmore | very smooth and mellow ale, not much taste to it though |
| Penn Dark Lager | 54 | 65 | tasted at 9th Annual GEIMF (#18) | Pittsburgh, PA |
| Penn Weissen | Not Listed | 80 | tasted at 9th Annual GEIMF (#21) | |
| Pete's ESP Lager | Not Listed | 45 | in bottles at Julia's | |
| Pete's Oktoberfest | Not Listed | 60 | Variety Brews, Moosic | probably the best Pete's I've had so far, still not that great though |
| Pete's Place Choc | | 65 | beer #204 at 2001 GABF | Krebs, OK |
| Pete's Strawberry Blonde | Not Listed | 50 | in bottles at Julia's | |
| Pete's Wicked Ale | 62 | 35 | in bottles at Julia's | not enjoyable at all |
| Pete's Wicked Summer Brew | 72 | 55 | 6 packs at Convenient, Moosic | |
| Pete's Wicked Winter Brew | 30 | 30 | 6 packs at Convenient, Moosic | |
| Phantom Canyon Zebulon's Peated Porter | | 60 | beer #106 at 2001 GABF | Colorado Springs, CO |
| Phantome | Not Listed | 85 | in big bottles at Sudds (6/22/00) | Very fruity, raspberry nose...Nice spicy and fruity saison style with from raspberry and even faint bubble gum characters...really! Very nice. |
| Pilsner Urquell | 79 | 50 | Variety Brews, Dunmore | a fraction of a hair better that all that other skunky smelling beer |
| Pinkus Organic Hefe-Weissen | | 40 | Premier Gourmet, Kenmore, NY (9/28/00) | starts off light a very light wheat beer, then just gets totally bland and odd tasting |
| Pioneer/Wisconsin Oscars Chocolate Oatmeal Stout | | 85 | beer #229 at 2001 GABF | Black River Falls, WI |
| Piraat | 98 | 90 | Premier Gourmet, Kenmore, NY (10/13/00) | another great tripel from Belgium...very strong alcoholic taste which mellows out nicely to a warm, wine-y aftertaste |
| Pizza Port Solana Beach Cuvee de Tomme | | 75 | beer #97 at 2001 GABF | Solana Beach, CA |
| Pizza Port Solana Beach The Mother of All Beers | | 85 | beer #96 at 2001 GABF | very good quad |
| Pizza Port Solana Beach SPF 45 Saison | | 70 | beer #95 at 2001 GABF | |
| Pizza Port Carlsbad Chronic | | 55 | beer #217 at 2001 GABF | made with hemp...clever name, eh? |
| Pizza Port Carlsbad SPA | | 70 | beer #89 at 2001 GABF | Carlbad, CA |
| Pizza Port Carlsbad Wipeout IPA | | 75 | beer #23 at 2001 GABF | |
| Portland Brewing Zig Zag River Lager | Not Listed | 65 | Kedda got a sampler case | Not much to say about any of these Portland brews...not much wrong with them, not much right though either |
| Portland Brewing MacTarnahan's Scottish Style Amber Ale | Not Listed | 55 | Kedda got a sampler case | not too too bad...didn't remind me of Ireland though and very weak for an amber |
| Portland Brewing Original Honey Beer | Not Listed | 45 | Kedda got a sampler case | not a molecule of honey in the thing |
| Post Road Snowshoe Ale | Not Listed | 40 | on tap at Montage Ski Resort | didn't taste like anything until I swallowed...very strange |
| Potomac Pale Ale | Not Listed | 65 | tasted no tap at Sudds | very smooth, pale ale, with a slighty dry aftertaste...very drinkable |
| Powerhouse Dunkles | | 60 | beer #79 at 2001 GABF | Sebastopol, CA |
| Prescott Ponderosa IPA | | 65 | beer #2 at 2001 GABF | Prescott, AZ |
| Prescott Raven Maniac Stout | | 75 | beer #107 at 2001 GABF | |
| Pumphouse Fireside White | | 80 | beer #167 at 2001 GABF | nice brew....Longmont, CO |
| Pumphouse Igniter Pale Ale | | 65 | beer #3 at 2001 GABF | |
| Pyramid Apricot Ale | 51 | 70 | tasted on tap at Blind Tiger, NYC (8/29/00) | very strong apricot nose, faint on the tongue though...get the DogFish Head Aprihop before this, if you can |
| Pyramid Broken Rake Amber | | 70 | bottle from Denver | |
| Pyramid Espresso Stout | 64 | 80 | got a case of 22oz. at Shangy's, Emmaus, PA | nice smoky beer, that actually tastes like its name! Excellent! |
| Pyramid Hefeweizen | | 65 | bottle from Denver | |
| Pyramid IPA | | 80 | bottle from Denver | |
| Pyramid Pale Ale | | 60 | bottle from Denver | |
| Pyramid Snow Cap | | 70 | beer #206 at 2001 GABF | |