Our Amazing 
Frontal Lobes
Why You Shouldn't Leave Home Without Them!

Presented by
Brooke J. Cannon, Ph.D.
Marywood University

University of Scranton
December 1, 2001


  
Q.  How did we first realize that the frontal lobes were important for daily life?

A.  Through a freak accident in 1848.

Consider the curious tale of Phineas Gage (1823-1860).  Phineas Gage was a railroad foreman of a railway track construction crew in Cavendish, Vermont.  To prepare the site for laying track, workers would drill holes in the ground and place a charge of dynamite inside.  To ensure that the charge was well placed, they used a tamping iron (see below) to firm it into the ground.  Mr. Gage was checking the dynamite laid by his men when a charge accidentally exploded, blowing the tamping iron point first under his left cheek bone and straight out the top of his head, landing 75 to 90 feet behind him!  Miraculously, Phineas was knocked over but not knocked out.  The left frontal lobe of his brain was visible through the open flap of scalp and skull.  Mr. Gage was treated and tended to by a young physician and actually returned to his home only 10 weeks later.  After about 6-8 months, Phineas felt strong enough to return to work.  His change in personality, however, was dramatic.  No longer could was he an efficient businessman, capable of planning, formulating and following goals, and effectively managing those who worked under his supervision.  Once an even-tempered man, he now was irritable, impatient, unable to attend to a task for any length of time.  He now would curse and was rude to others.  His friends said that he was "No longer Gage."

 
Phineas Gage's 1850 life mask
This is a plaster mask of Phineas Gage, made while he was still alive.  You can see where the tamping iron came out of the top of his head.
Here is a photograph of the actual tamping iron.  It is 3 feet 7 inches long and weighs just under 14 pounds.  It is about 1 inch in diameter at one end, tapering to a point at the other end. Tamping Iron
Harlow's 1868 photo of Gage's skull
This is Phineas Gage's skull, where the damage can clearly be seen.
To learn more about Phineas Gage, visit 
The Phineas Gage site in Australia
 
Q.  So our frontal lobes are important for our personalities and for behaving properly and effectively in society.  How do they affect our thinking?

A.  By allowing us to not act on our first impulses, to do 2 different things at once, and to be flexible in our thinking.  Here are some examples.

The Stroop Effect

First discovered by a man named Stroop in 1935, the Stroop effect shows us that reading becomes an "automatic" behavior when presented with words.  Try the following:

Read these words.
 

RED
BLUE
GREEN
BROWN
RED
YELLOW
YELLOW
RED
BLUE
GREEN
 
As quickly as you can, name these colors.
 
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
XXXX
 
As quickly as you can, name the color of the following words.
 
CUP
DOOR
HORSE
TABLE
BELL
STOP
PEN
SMILE
DESK
MOON

Now, name the color of these words.
 

RED
BLUE
GREEN
BROWN
RED
YELLOW
YELLOW
RED
BLUE
GREEN

Is it harder naming the colors of the words than the XXXs?  Why?

Because your brain was distracted by wanting to read the word, especially when the word is one of the possible answers!

Did you find yourself wanting to read the word?  If you were able to not read the word and instead to name the color of the ink, then your frontal lobes are working!  They allowed you to keep from saying the wrong answer, even though you might have "said" it in your head.

This ability to keep from saying something wrong or inappropriate helps you with your friendships and keeps you out of the principal's office!

Visit this Interactive Stroop Effect Experiment by Dr. Chudler to time yourself and to learn more about the Stroop Effect.

On the NOVA site, they have a fun version of the Stroop and a good image of the brain location likely to be related to the Stroop effect.

For another online version of the Stroop Effect, visit the Discover Magazine NeuroQuest site.

 
Divided Attention

Can you count from 1 to 26 and say the alphabet at the same time, going back and forth between numbers and letters (1-A-2-B-3-C...)?  This is an example of divided attention.  Your frontal lobes allow you to keep track of where you are in the numbers and the letters and directs you to not say two numbers or two letters in a row. 

This is how you can play Nintendo and talk to your friends at the same time!

Want to try this in a cool on-line test?  Visit Discover Magazines NeuroQuest, where there are other fun brain teasers, too!
 
Flexible Thinking

How are the following two things alike?
 

Apple-Orange
Orange-Blue
Blue-Happy
Happy-Doc
Hand-Foot
Foot-Yard
Pitch-Slide
Slide-Swing

Could you figure them all out?  Were some easier than others?  You can thank your frontal lobes for helping you see connections between the words and for allowing you to understand different ways to think of some words.
 

Try another test of mental flexibility.

Divide these 6 stimuli into 2 groups according to some characteristic.  Now divide them into 2 new groups, by using a different strategy.  Again, your frontal lobes helped you think of other ways to put these objects into categories.
 

Sandwich
hot dog.jpg (15107 bytes)
***
***
Honey

Mental flexibility allows you to figure out possible solutions to problems you might face and to consider alternate explanations for events.
 
 

Well, I hope you've had fun exercising your frontal lobes!

If you feel like writing about your brain, why don't you enter the Neuroscience for Kids Writing Contest!  Deadline is February 1, 2002.  Good luck!