The Star and Sentinel (Carlisle, Pennsylvania, Saturday, January 31,
1914 [ancestry.com, historical newspaper]
Carlisle Superintendent Ordered to Return to Post
Investigation of Indian School Management may Take Wider Steps
Washington, Jan. 24.-Moses Friedman, superintendent of the Carlisle
Indian School, whose management is under thorough investigation by Indian
Commissioner Sells, was ordered to return to his post.
While here Mr. Friedman took occasion to say that the charges against
him were instigated by General R. H. Pratt, former head of the school and
its first superintendent. Commissioner Sells refused to hear any countercharges,
and that his place was at Carlisle and not in Washington, having come here
without sanction of the bureau.
The charges are against the administration of Mr. Friedman, and in
no way affect the school itself.
The investigators also may inquire into the action of Judge Sadler,
of Cumberland County, in sending a young girl and Indian boy to jail for
60 days for an offense which, under the Pennsylvania laws, is merely punishable
by a fine. The Federal Government is thoroughly aroused over the confining
of its wards in jail.
Some of the charges preferred against the superintendent set forth
that liquor was used by the Indians in the school: that more than one-third
of the scholars allege that Mr. Friedman is incompetent; that the attitude
of the superintendent became so offensive to the scholars that they hissed
him when he appeared before then, and that the commission of certain offenses
by the Indian shows more than anything else a deplorable lack of discipline.
Carlisle, Pa., Jan. 24.-Superintendent Friedman, of the Carlisle Indian
Schol [sic], concerning whose administration formal criticisms have been
made at Washington, returned to Carlisle to-day. He said he welcomed any
fair investigation and the more thorough it was the better he would like.
************************************************************************
Adams County News (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) January 31, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspaper]
Indian School Trouble Again
Carlisle Indian School Superintendent States that he would Welcome
an Investigation. Various Charges are Alleged, it is Said.
"I will welcome any fair investigation, and the more thorough the better.
The record of the school speaks for itself."
Thus spoke Superintendent Moses Friedman, of the Carlisle Indian School,
upon his return to Carlisle from Washington when asked for a statement
regarding the recent charges brought against him and the school. Continuing,
Mr. Friedman stated that he would have a further statement to issue to
the public, probably next week.
According to some citizens in Carlisle who have been defending the
superintendent, Mr. Friedman will not tolerate incompetency [sic] about
the school and it is said that during the past year quite a number of employes
who have been under civil service have been dropped for cause and that
they are back of the investigation.
Mr. Friedman claims the record made by the school since he has been
in charge speaks for itself, and residents of Carlisle who favor his retention
say that he has vigorously prosecuted charges of illegal sale of liquor
to Indian students. It is said, too, that Mr. Friedman devotes all of his
time to the school and that he has reased [raised] the standard of the
athletic and academic courses.
While in Washington Mr. Friedman took occasion to say that the charges
against him were instigated by Colonel R. H. Pratt, former head of the
school and its first superintendent. Commissioner Sells refused to hear
any counter-charges, and informed Mr. Friedman that his place was at Carlisle
and not in Washington, having gone there without sanction of the bureau.
Some of the charges preferred against the superintendent set forth
that liquor was used by the Indians in the school; that more than one-third
of the scholars allege Mr. Friedman is incompetent; that the attitude of
the superintendent became so offensive to the scholars that they hissed
him when he appeared before them, and that the commission of certain offenses
by the Indians shows more than anything else a deplorable lack of discipline.
Plan to Make Better Indians
Bill Introduced Providing for Additional Courses at Carlisle. Paper
of that Town Rises in Defense of Friedman.
A more advanced curriculum and manual training features of broader
scope will be inaugurated at the Carlisle Indian School, if the recommendations
of the House Committee on Indian Affairs prevail. This committee favorably
considered the raising of the school's standard on Saturday and at the
same time approved of its annual appropriation of $152,000.
There is a great difference of opinion as to the needs for the establishment
of higher education for Indians. Those who are familiar with the subject
say that while the Indian has made great strides in intellectual and material
development, he is not sufficiently advanced in academic branches to justify
teaching in university studies.
As a result of expert opinion the House Committee recommended a gradual
raising of the course at Carlisle to include some of the studies embraced
in the best high schools and an extension of the manual training course.
It is proposed to teach the Indian practical trades that will fit him to
take his place beside the white boy.
The Carlisle Herald is quick to resent the charges said to have been
brought against the superintendent of the school, saying in an editorial:
"The Indian school should be protected. The present investigation might
develop into a pretext made up of false fabric for the removal of the school
from Carlisle to some point in the west. If this should culminate, the
blame will be justly placed on Carlisle residents, for it is on complaints
based on selfish motives originated in Carlisle that have caused the present
situation.
"A canvass made of responsible citizens who are in touch with the affairs
of the Indian school, shows how the conduct of the institution is regarded
in Carlisle. Mr. Friedman is held in the highest personal esteem. He has
been energetic in broadening the curriculum of the school and extending
its practical courses, adopting several new and valuable ideas. He has
worked constantly in upbuilding the school. When he came here the condition
of the buildings and grounds was pathetic. To-day the campus and its adjoining
structures, are models of neatness and architectural beauty. The buildings
which were once unsanitary shack, are in the best condition."
************************************************************************
Adams County News (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) February 7, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspaper]
Will Not Move Indian School
Investigation at Carlisle School Will not Cause its Removal to Western
State, Says Authority of the Matter.
A Washington dispatch to the Philadelphia Ledger under date of January
30, says:
"In truth, the statement must be made that all those interested in
the care of the Indians, including members of congressional committees,
had no ulterior purpose in ordering the investigation. There has been no
agitation here, despite the assertions at Carlisle, that the inquiry has
as its ultimate purpose the removal of the school from Carlisle.
"As a matter of fact, the present investigation is only one of the
many conducted by the new commissioner, who has announced his policy of
reorganizing the Indian Bureau and freeing it from politics and incompetence.
The opinion expressed is that the agitation at Carlisle will have no effect
upon the situation. Commissioner Sells told the Public Ledger correspondent
that the issues injected into the trouble by citizens of Carlisle would
not be considered, and that the inquiry would proceed upon unprejudiced
and judicial lines.
"Without entering into the various charges, he said that the question
was whether or not they were true. If the investigation being conducted
by Inspector Linnen shows that the charges alleged by the Indian Rights
Association are unfounded, Superintendent Friedman would be upheld. On
the other hand, he told of summary dismissal of another superintendent
of a Western school as illustrative of his action in Superintendent Friedman's
case should the serious features of the charges be sustained.
"I may say to those interested in the Carlisle School that the investigation
bears solely upon the management of the school", he added, "and in no way
is intended to find reasons for its removal. The policy of the bureau is
fixed. Carlisle School will be continued. It is one of the best in the
country, and the Government has too much money invested there ever to consider
its removal."
"The investigation will be completed in the next week."
************************************************************************
Gettysburg Times (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania), Saturday, February 7,
1914 [ancestry.com, historical newspaper]
Probers Visit Indian School
Come into Carlisle Suddenly and Without Advising Superintendent. Hearings
are Held Privately by Investigating Committee.
A committee acting under a joint resolution of the National Senate
and House dropped unexpectedly into Carlisle last evening, and, without
notifying Superintendent Friedman, of the Carlisle Indian School, of their
presence, pre-empted quarters, and together with J. Linnen. a Government
Indian Office inspector, who has been in Carlisle for some days, conducted
what is reported to be an investigation of the Indian School and its management.
This report is given strength by the fact that it is known that a number
of persons recognized as unfriendly to Friedman and the school, either
or both were heard.
The commission consisted of Senators Robinson and Lane and Representatives
Carter and Stevens. Newspaper men were refused admission by the secretary
of the commission, R. B. Keating.
Congressman Arthur R. Rupley, who met the commission at Carlisle, and
who has recently denied making charges concerning the Indian school, said
that the meeting was public, although access would not be given members
of the press by Chairman Robinson.
Considerable indignation was shown by Carlisle people of prominence
last evening at what looked like a star-chamber meeting.
Secretary Keating averred that the commission had given no notice to
anyone of its arrival or its intention to come; but his statement was hardly
corroborated by appearances.
************************************************************************
Gettysburg Times (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania), Saturday, February 10,
1914 [ancestry.com, historical newspaper]
Irregularities at Indian School
Are Unsatisfactory and Must be Corrected, Says, Senator.
To Continue the Probe
Superintendent Friedman Declares He Welcomes Investigation of U. S.
Commission.
Washington, Feb. 10.-Senator Robinson, head of a special commission
which investigated conditions at the Carlisle Indian school, reports affairs
there as being unsatisfactory, and announces that a more thorough probe
will be made.
He complains of discipline or lack of it, moral conditions and discouragement
of athletics. He said:
"The joint commission to investigate Indian affairs, visited the Carlisle
school for Indians, at Carlisle, Pa., the latter part of last week. The
testimony of many pupils and employes of the school was taken, as was also
that of several citizens of the town of Carlisle. Among the matters investigated
were the general disciplinary and moral conditions prevailing in the school,
the academic and demonstration work, and the method of disbursing the athletic
funds.
"The commission does not desire at this time to discuss the matter
at length, the welfare of the school and its importance being the primary
consideration. We have no hesitancy in saying that the conditions at Carlisle
are, in many respects, unsatisfactory and require correction."
Senator Robinson said the joint committee visited Carlisle for the
purpose of investigating conditions generally prevailing in the school.
Among the complaints, he said, were charges of laxity of discipline, unjust
expulsion of students, misrepresentation of the school to the public generally
by the school authorities and to the Indian bureau; alleged unsanitary
conditions; complaints as to the quality and quantity of the food, and
also complaints against alleged unjust punishment.
Moses Friedman, superintendent of the school, says he welcomes a fair
investigation. In 1904 Mr. Frieman [sic] took a government position at
the Indian school at Phoenix, Ariz. From 1904 to 1906 he organized industrial
training schools in the Phillippines [sic] and then became assistant superintendent
of Haskell institute, at Lawrence, Kan., an Indian school. Since April
1, 1908, he has been the superintendent of Carlisle.
************************************************************************
Gettysburg Times (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania), Friday, February 13, 1914
[ancestry.com, historical newspaper]
Suspend School Superintendent
Moses Friedman, Superintendent of Carlisle Indian School, is Suspended
Pending Further Investigation by Commission. The Charges.
Indian Commissioner Cato Sells has suspended Moses Friedman, Superintendent
of Carlisle Indian School, pending further investigation, on charges of
lack of discipline. Indian Supervisor O. H. Lipps was assigned temporarily
to the management of the school.
Charges have been preferred to Congress that under the management of
Superintendent Friedman loose morals prevailed in the school, and that
many Indian girls sent there for instruction came to moral grief.
Conditions at the school were investigated recently by a special congressional
commission headed by Senator Robinson, Arkansas. The preliminary report
of the commission was damaging to the school management and a more complete
investigation was recommended.
Senator Robinson gave out a statement in which the commission reports
trouble with discipline at the school, complains of moral conditions existing
there and deplores failure on the part of the school management to encourage
athletics. Details of moral conditions complained of are withheld by the
commission.
Commissioner Sells, having the intimate report of the commission, promptly
suspended Friedman and Stauffer and has directed a searching inquiry by
investigators of his department. There is co-education of Indian boys and
girls at Carlisle School. It is one of the oldest Indian schools maintained
by the Government, and its graduates have been sent among the Indian tribes
as missionaries in the cause of education and civilization.
The news of his suspension was a surprise to Superintendent Friedman,
who said that he did not care to talk for publication, further than to
say that he hoped to have the opportunity of showing that his administration
at Carlisle was effective and did not merit condemnation in any instance.
Director of Music Claude M. Stauffer, of the Carlisle Indian School,
has also been suspended. The bandmaster is not now in Carlisle, nor is
he represented there by counsel.
It is not believed that the recent investigation will affect more officials
at Carlisle.
************************************************************************
The Evening Sentinel, Friday 13, 1914, Cumberland County Historical
Society (microfilm)
Friedman Suspended
Bandmaster C. M. Stouffer Also Relieved of Duties
Results of Investigation
Congressional Committee Orders Superintendent Friedman to Trial-Hints
at More Charges
A special dispatch from the Public Ledger's Washington Bureau, says:
Washington, Feb. 12-Cato Sells, commissioner of Indian Affairs, today
suspended Moses Friedman, superintendent of the Carlisle, Pa., Indian School
and also Bandmaster Stauffer. . . .
. . . Some of the charges made against Friedman are directed against
his action in reference to misconduct of students. The matter came to a
climax some months ago when Friedman had a girl and boy arrested and sent
to court. They were remanded to jail and kept there 60 days. The committee
holds that this action shows more than anything else Friedman's incompetence.
According to a member of the committee a girl was punished by Stauffer,
who used a club and inflicted severe injuries. Upon being confronted with
the charge, Stauffer admitted that he had administered corporal punishment.
He was upheld by the superintendent. Another charge against the latter
is that he failed to provide proper rations and the girls frequently had
to forego bread, so that the boys, who had worked on the farm or in manual
labor, might have a supply.
Senator Lane said today that the attempt made by Friedman to win sympathy,
on the ground that the inquiry was undertaken to effect the school's removal
was absolutely groundless.
"As the charges against Mr. Friedman become public this impression
will disappear", said Senator Lane. "The committee and every one interested
in Indian affairs are convinced that the school should remain at Carlisle.
Its efficiency and management will be strengthened as the result of the
impartial inquiry under way. The bill founding the school provided that
it should come under military supervision and the inquiry has convinced
many members of the commission that this should be done speedily.
Hints at More Charges
Matthew K. Sniffen, secretary of the Indian Rights Association, which
preferred the charges against Superintendent Moses Friedman, of the Carlisle
Indian School, yesterday said that the suspension of the superintendent
and bandmaster, ordered by Commissioner Sells, did not surprise him, as
he was expecting such an outcome.
"This association," said Mr. Sniffen, "has never yet made charges which
it has not been able to sustain." . . .
. . . "At the proper time", said he, "we will be ready to present our
facts to the public. Until then we must remain silent."
Lipps Here
Oscar C. Lipps, supervisor in the U. S. Indian Bureau at Washington,
D. C., has arrived here and is in charge of the Carlisle School.
To a Sentinel reporter, Mr. Lipps stated that he did not expect to
remain here long. He arrived last night. He stated that he has been in
the Indian service for some time, and was connected with western institutions,
among them Chilocco, Oklahoma, where are several former Carlislers. He
has been to Carlisle once or twice before and has sent a goodly number
of students to this school. He is here under orders of the bureau and has
taken charge of the school.
************************************************************************
Adams County News (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) February 14, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspaper]
Hear Complaints
To Find Out How Things are Going at Indian School
Senators Robinson, Arkansas, and Lane, Oregon, and Representative Carter,
Oklahoma, and Stephens, Texas, constituting a joint sub-committee of the
Indian Affairs Committee of the two houses of Congress, on Saturday continued
their investigation of affairs at the Carlisle Indian School . . . Senator
Robinson . . . said "There are some other matters relating to the accounts
of the superintendent connected with the athletic fund, and his accounts
as superintendent that are under investigation."
************************************************************************
Source unknown, newspaper clipping, date 1914, Society of American
Indian Papers, Reel 8, Part II, Series 1, correspondence
First:
Spanking for a Girl Cause of Carlisle Row
Suspension of Superintendent of Indian School Brings About Serious
Dissension.
Carlisle, Pa., Feb. 11 [illegible]. The Carlisle Indian School today
was threatened with a serious dissension because of the suspension of Superintendent
Moses Friedman supposedly for the spanking of an Indian girl pupil.
The school authorities made no statement about the action against Friedman
but it was understood and freely stated among the students and members
of the faculty that Friedman was suspended because he ordered an official
of the school to spank a refractory[?] girl.
The corporal punishment it was said was ordered by the superintendent
and the matron of the girl's department.
Second:
U. S. Investigates Carlisle Scandal
Inquiry Into Books of Football Team; Flogging of Indians Charged.
Washington, Feb. 15.-Following the suspension of Superintendent Freidman,
the books of the Carlisle Indian School have been turned over to the Department
of Justice for investigation. It is intimated that criminal prosecutions
are likely to follow.
Notably among the accounts which are said to be in confusion are those
fo the famous Carlisle football eleven. It is alleged that receipts from
the big fames played by the eleven are missing and the government officials
are trying to find where the money has gone.
In addition to the removal of Superintendent Friedman a shake-up of
the entire teaching and general staff of the school is impending. The school
payroll amounts to about $50,000 a year.
Flogging of Indian students, improper food, misconduct and incompetent
management and teaching are some of he charges developed by an investigation
conducted by Indian Inspector Linnen and the joint Commission on Indian
Affairs headed by Senator Robinson of Arkansas.
Abuses in connection with the "farming out" of Indian children have
been uncovered, with the result that the practice will be abolished. In
addition to bad food it is charged that no knives or forks were allowed
many of the children, who reverted to the aboriginal method of eating.
Gross misconduct involving employes and girl students are alleged to
have been found. It is charged that these laxities were generally known
and overlooked by those whose duty it was to safeguard the inmates of the
school.
Similar conditions at other Indian institutions are alleged to exist
and a quiet, but sweeping, investigation is now being carried on under
the direction of the joint commission. ************************************************************************
Adams County News (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) February 21, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
Friedman Says No Charges Yet
Superintendent at Carlisle Indian School Says he Has Received no Formal
Notification of the Charges against him.
Superintendent Friedman of the Carlisle Indian School, now under suspension,
who is involved in charges now under consideration by the Indian office,
was asked what charges had been made.
The suspended superintendent said that he himself and, so far as he
knows, no one else of the official staff at the Indian school, had received
a copy of the charges. He said that the published statement from Washington
to this effect was inaccurate and that he had no way of telling what he
was charged with except by inference and newspaper reports.
The rumor that emanated from Washington to the effect that the Musical
Director Claude M. Stauffer had beaten a girl with a club, was answered
by Stauffer's friends, in his absence from Carlisle. It is said that there
was a serious infraction of discipline in the school and that the matron
asked that the girl involved be spanked.
The bandmaster was asked by the matron to perform the task, his friends
say, and in the presence of the head matron, the school principal and the
outing manager, the punishment was administered. A piece of wood, a quarter
of an inch by three inches, broken from a soap box, was used and the punishment
was very light, according to the witnesses. The girl wrote Mr. Stauffer
a letter after the spanking, expressing sorrow for her misdeed and thanking
him for what he had done, declaring herself that she deserved it, it is
said.
Stauffer had been a loyal supporter of the Friedman administration.
His friends say that he had a stormy interview with Inspector J. Linnen.
No other Indian school official is known to have received charges.
************************************************************************
Adams County News (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) March 28, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
Employees Did Not Testify
Carlisle Indian School Matter Takes Another Turn when Employees are
not Allowed to Testify at Hearing.
Case Continued.
Bitter accusations featured the hearing before Justice Hughes in Carlisle
on Thursday in which Chief Clerk Siceni Nori, of the Carlisle Indian School,
who has been charged before the State courts with embezzlement by suspended
Superintendent Friedman, of the Carlisle School, was the defendant. Friedman
alleges that Nori took student money deposited there for transportation.
Assistant United States District Attorney John McCort, of Wilkes-Barre,
advised government employes subpoenaed on the case to refuse to give information
to the State courts, pleading so-called governmental privilege. Magistrate
Hughes adjourned the hearing until April 24 at the request of Friedman's
counsel, who said they would furnish evidence then.
Attorney Weizel, for the prosecution, accused the United States Government
officials of protecting a criminal and defied them to prosecute Nori before
the Federal authorities. He said Friedman's State prosecution would be
abandoned immediately when the Federal officials raised their protecting
arm from Nori and brought Federal action.
McCort said that he would not allow government employes who were asked
to testify and begged the magistrate not to allow himself to become a partner
in what he insinuated was a fishing expedition to get information from
the government superintendent.
Friedman took the stand and told all he knew of the handling of student
money at Carlisle. Nori's attorneys, Berg and McCort, refused to cross-examine
him.
Inspector Linnen, who had had charge of the Carlisle School investigation,
declined to produce any government papers without departmental orders and
would not say if he knew of any embezzlement by Nori. McCort wanted the
proceedings quashed because he averred that Federal laws covered such cases
and that Nori was a government ward answerable to Uncle Sam alone. Friedman's
attorneys argued that Nori was not a government ward, that the reservation
was under State law for criminal causes, as it was never ceded to the Federal
Government.
************************************************************************
Gettysburg Times (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) March 30, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
New Sensation
Boy Said to Have Destroyed Records Showing Misuse of Funds.
The criminal prosecution of Moses Friedman, the suspended superintendent
of Carlisle Indian School, as well as his discharge from office, may result
from evidence obtained by Commissioner of Indian Affairs Cato Sells within
the week.
Commissioner Sells has in his possession an affidavit from Siceni Nori,
secretary to Superintendent Friedman, that he destroyed papers tending
to show that funds belonging to the school had been misappropriated by
Friedman. The Indian boy alleges that he burned the evidence at the direction
of the suspended superintendent. Nori's affidavit was obtained by Chief
Inspector of the Indian Bureau Littie, after the former had indicated to
a joint Congressional Commission on Indian Affairs the character of the
papers missing from the files at Carlisle.
Close upon the submission of Nori's affidavit to the Indian Bureau
came the arrest of the Indian at Carlisle on the charge of having destroyed
property owned by the Government. The suspicion has arisen in the minds
of officials that the arrest was instigated by Friedman or his friends
to get at the information which had been divulged to the Government.
************************************************************************
Adams County News (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) April 4, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
Nori Has Also Been Suspended
Further Development at Carlisle School Results in Suspension of Clerk
Who is Said to have Admitted Destroying Papers.
Seconi [sic] Nori, chief clerk of the Indian School at Carlisle, who
made a confession last week declaring that he had destroyed evidence of
the misuse of money at the instigation of Moses Friedman, suspended superintendent
of the school, was also suspended Wednesday by Cato Sells Commissioner
of Indian Affairs
Hist suspension resulted from the transmission of his confession and
evidence taken by the special committee headed by Senator Robinson. It
is announced that this evidence shows Nori culpable and there is a doubt
in the minds of officials whether the confession has a great deal of truth
in it.
In ordering his suspension Commissioner Sells ordered a hearing. This
hearing will bring to a focus the financial transactions at Carlisle in
which Nori implicated the accused superintendent. Such a procedure will
take the case against Nori out of the courts of Pennsylvania and transfer
it to the Federal Authorities. Moses Friedman will be subpoenaed to appear
and defend himself and the result of the investigation will undoubtedly
decide the case not only against Nori but Friedman as well.
The opinion prevails that the suspended Indian clerk, Superintendent
Friedman and Bandmaster Stauffer who was suspended a month ago will be
dismissed from the service.
Developments also indicated that criminal procedure will follow. The
government officials are determined to make those responsible for the misuse
of funds pay a severe penalty.
************************************************************************
Adams County News (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) May 2, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
More Trouble at Carlisle School
Another Employe at Government School Has Charge against him.
Conditions there Getting More Unsatisfactory.
Do not Like Delay.
Acting Superintendent Lipps, of the Carlisle Indian School, has reported
to Commissioner of Indian Affairs Sells, at Washington, that the demoralization
there is increasing.
A cook, he stated in a formal charge, had taken one of the Indian boys
to a saloon in Carlisle and bought him liquor. This is against the law,
and the cook is subject to a fine and imprisonment.
Commissioner Sells, with the new charge before him, has four cases
to dispose of in connection with the Carlisle school. He will act on them
at the same time, and indications are that all those accused will be dismissed
and some proceeded against criminally.
Those accused are:
Moses Friedman, superintendent, suspended on the charge of incompetence
and permitting irregularities regarding the funds to exist.
W. K. Stauffer, bandmaster, suspended for clubbing an Indian girl.
Seceni Nori, chief clerk, charged with misappropriating funds and destroying
documents.
The fourth charge is that just made against the cook.
Representatives of the Indian Rights Association, with headquarters
in Philadelphia, are becoming impatient at the delay of Commissioner Sells
in formally acting. The investigation against the first three men was completed
more than a month ago.
Since that time, the acting superintendent reports, the demoralization
at the school has grown, because the Indian pupils believe that pressure
had been brought to save the men they think should have been dismissed
long ago.
Political and other pressure has been used upon Commissioner Sells
in behalf of Mr. Friedman. Those who know Commissioner Sells say that he
cannot be swayed by any influence, no matter how powerful.
************************************************************************
Adams County News (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) May 16, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
School Troubles
Several Resign from Carlisle Indian School, Recent Developments.
Resignations of Moses Friedman, superintendent, and S. J. Nori, chief
clerk of the Carlisle Indian School, were accepted Monday be Cato Sells,
commissioner of Indian Affairs. Two person holding minor positions at the
school were transferred, and another was removed.
Charges were filed several months ago against Friedman, Nori and other
officials at the school and a congressional committee instituted an investigation
which resulted in Friedman's suspension. In accepting the resignations
Commissioner Sells stated that action did not indicate the attitude the
bureau on any phase of the accusations.
The charges investigated by the congressional committee included laxity
of discipline, unjust expulsion of students and misrepresentations of the
school to the public by officials of the institution.
Findings in the case, Mr. Sells said, had been referred to the Department
of Justice for such action as it sees fit to take.
Commissioner Sells announced that a special officer of the bureau,
who had been at Carlisle recently, apprehended five men selling liquor
to Indian students.
************************************************************************
Star and Sentinel (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) June 13, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
Friedman Blames Politics
A desire on the part of the present Democratic administration to oust
as many of the Republican office holders as possible to make room for appointees
of their own, is blamed by Moses Friedman, who recently resigned as superintendent
of the Carlisle Indian School, for the attacks on the school which resulted
in the resignation of Mr. Friedman and the veiled threats to prosecute
Glenn Warner, the football coach, for alleged misuse of the athletic fund
of the institution.
************************************************************************
Star and Sentinel (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) July 11, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
Indian School Head May Not Be Prosecuted
Former Superintendent Friedman Immune-Limitation Cuts Out Action.
The investigation of conditions at the Carlisle Indian School by a commission
appointed for that purpose, which lead to charges against Moses Friedman
for irregularities during his incumbency as superintendent, seems to have
met serious obstacles in so far as prosecution of the defendant is concerned.
This does not mean that Mr. Friedman has been exonerated but Attorney General
McReynolds has decided that the statute of limitations has run against
the most serious offenses alleged to have been committed by Mr. Friedman.
A general shake up followed the investigation of affairs at Carlisle
and for a time matters looked rather gloomy for the Superintendent, although
he insisted that the attack against him was made purely out of jealous
motives. Glen Warner, the famous football coach was charged with irregularities
as were Hugh R. Miller and E. L. Martin, news paper correspondents who
though not connected with the School are alleged to have received money
for boosting the athletics, at the instigation of Coach Warner.
Secretary of the Interior, Lane is waiting on a detailed report from
the Department of Justice on the legal aspects of the charges against Superintendent
Friedman, but it is known that the report will explain that the particular
offenses charged are now covered by the statute of limitations. The testimony
of Chief Clerk Miller, Siceni Nori, and several others brought out at the
hearing before the Commissioner of Indian affair satisfied the Department
of the Interior and Mr. McReynolds of the irregularities of the Superintendent.
There are some other charges as to acts said not to be covered by the
statute of limitations, but the Department of Justice feels that insufficient
evidence has been brought forward. Further investigation may be made in
certain quarters, but there is a general impression that Friedman will
go scot free.
************************************************************************
Adams County News (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) July 11, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
Friedman Wants Investigation
Scorns Immunity Offer Made by Federal Official and Says Things at Carlisle
Indian School Must be thoroughly Shown.
Moses Friedman, until recently superintendent of the Carlisle Indian
School, has indignantly thrown down the offer of the Department of Justice
to drop further inquiry into his administration of the Carlisle School,
and challenged the Government to complete the investigation which was instigated
by the Bureau of Indian Affairs. Mr. Friedman, who has been visiting friends
in Philadelphia since he resigned from the superintendency of the school
late in May, was aroused by the publication yesterday of a dispatch from
Washington which said that the Department of Justice had decided to take
no further notice of the case because the acts alleged against Mr. Friedman
are now covered by the statute of limitations.
"I want this inquiry to go on, until as must be the result, my reputation
is vindicated and the conditions which drove me to resign are shown to
be the result of a carefully planned persecution at the hands of the Bureau
of Indian Affairs, under Commissioner Sells. The intimation that I was
dismissed on account of irregularities and incompetency, and that the charges
were established in a fair investigation, is one more manifestation of
the campaign which has been directed against me and which I can no longer
endure in silence.
"As for the accusations of irregularities in the finances of the school,
there is not one transaction for which I cannot render an account. That
the testimony of Nori, shifting the blame for his defalcations upon me,
should have been accepted shows the malignance of the attack upon me. During
my incumbency, I handled $2,000,000 of the school funds. My accounts show
that not one penny of it was misappropriated.
"I would prefer anything in the world than to have this matter dropped
while the impression is spread abroad that I ought to be grateful for the
'leniency' of the Department of Justice in deciding that it will not prosecute
me," he declared. "All that I have in the world is my character. I cannot
suffer this injustice, which seeks relentlessly to ruin me, to go on. I
have absolutely nothing to fear from the most searching inquiry that can
be brought to bear upon the matter. I welcome it. But it is those who have
made me the object of their persecution who ought to fear such publicity;
for I declare there exists in the Bureau of Indian Affairs a system of
star chamber inquisition which if allowed to grow, will result in an impairment
of the efficiency in the Federal service so grave that the Administration
must take steps to stamp it out or else mock at justice."
************************************************************************
Star and Sentinel (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) November 14, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
Will Not Be Tried In Cumberland County
The case of Mr. Nori, the Indian Clerk of Superintendent Friedman,
of the Carlisle Indian School, who was to have been tried in connection
with alleged mismanagement disclosed by investigation at the school recently,
will not come up in Cumberland County Court, at Carlisle, where it was
listed. A telegram was received by District Attorney Alexander from the
U. S. District Attorney, stating that the U. S. District Court will present
a bill of indictment against Nori before the Grand Jury of the U. S. District
Court. ************************************************************************
Adams County News (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) December 19, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
Indian School Difficulties will be Followed Up.
As a result of the insistence of the Interior Department that there
be no let-up in the prosecution of charges of mismanagement at the Carlisle
Indian School, bills of indictment will be presented to the grand jury
at Scranton, within the next two weeks.
Moses L. Friedman, formerly superintendent of the school, and S. J.
Neri [sic], a clerk, are the men against whom the charges are pressed.
************************************************************************
Adams County News (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) January 16, 1915 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
Say They Burned Public Records
Charges against Indian School Officials Matter for Hearing before Federal
Grand Jury. True Bills in Three Indictments.
Three true bills were found by a Federal Court grand jury against S.
J. Nori, former chief clerk, and Moses Friedman, former superintendent
of the Carlisle Indian School at Sunbury on Thursday. On one bill both
are charged with destroying and burning public records. On a second bill
four counts are found against each, charging embezzling of public moneys,
and on a third Friedman alone is indicted charged with embezzling receipts
from the sale of tickets at athletic games.
According to the first indictment, the two former Federal officials
are charged with "willfully destroying and burning records and papers in
the form of written receipts for moneys." The allegations cover twenty
receipts which were given, it is charged, by S. J. Nori for individual
Indian student accounts, which before then had been transferred by William
N. Miller, financial clerk of the school, to Nori as chief clerk for use
by road transportation for Indian students, the names of whom are unknown
because of the destruction of these receipts. The specific allegation is
that these receipts were burned on or about the 10th of March, 1914.
Both are jointly indicted on four counts in the second indictment.
It is alleged that it was their duty, the indictment says, to take care
of moneys belonging to the students until such time as they were needed
for payment of the expenses incurred by these students in traveling from
their homes in remote parts of the United States to Carlisle.
These moneys are usually placed on deposit for the students to their
credit with the Farmers' Trust Company, of Carlisle, according to the indictment,
subject to withdrawal check by the individual student to whom it belongs,
but only upon the written approval of the superintendent and supervision
of the chief clerk, and under the law they are charged with the safekeeping
of this money.
Some of it, it is alleged, was appropriated by them. These alleged
embezzlements are said to have taken place between January 20, 1912, and
January 20, 1914. The specific charges are for sums totaling $167.90.
In the third indictment Friedman is alone charged with the alleged
embezzlement of $5.72 from the sale of tickets of admission to athletic
games during November, 1912.
Trial of the case has been set for the first Monday in March at Scranton.
************************************************************************
Star and Sentinel (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) May 15, 1915 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
Lipps Made Head of Carlisle School
Supervisor in Charge Appointed Superintendent of Institution by Indian
Commissioner
Washington, May 13.-Oscar H. Lipps, who has been the supervisor in charge
at the Carlisle Indian School since Moses P. Friedman was dismissed was
appointed superintendent of the school yesterday by Cato Sells, Indian
Commissioner. Mr. Lipps has been at the head of the institution for nearly
a year, and in the opinion of Commissioner Sells has showed himself absolutely
qualified.
Mr. Lipps entered the Indian service as a teacher in 1898. He had been
superintendent of an Indian school in Utah, where he acted as supervisor
of the farms and later as supervisor of the school.
************************************************************************
Adams County News (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) May 15, 1915 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
Hear Testimony
Former Indian School Superintendent is Indicted.
Dr. Moses Friedman, former superintendent of the Carlisle Indian School,
and S. J. Nori, former chief clerk, were indicted by the Federal Grand
Jury at Sunbury on Friday on charges of misappropriating funds collected
at athletic events of the school and for making illegal use of money furnished
for traveling expenses of the athletes.
Friedman and Nori resigned from the school after an investigation into
its affairs had been started by the government.
Two Indian maidens were brought in from the West to testify against
them. Miss Margaret Buffalo, a Chippewa girl, told the grand jury of alleged
transactions with the pair, saying that she gave Friedman and Nori money
to keep for her that never was returned. Susie Wallace , a Crow Indian
maiden, who was a student at Carlisle, made a similar statement.
Nori appeared as a witness against his former chief. It is understood
that he has turned State's evidence and has declared that any money that
he received from Indians that was not accounted had passed from his hands,
and that he could produce receipts for it.
The pair were indicted last January on charges of embezzlement and
failure to make satisfactory accounting of money received from the Athletic
Association of the school. This case has been continued to the October
term.
************************************************************************
Star and Sentinel (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) June 19, 1914 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
Friedman Goes Free
Former Head of Carlisle School Acquitted of Graft Charges In U. S.
Court
Williamsport, June 17.-Dr. Moses Friedman former superintendent of
the Carlisle Indian school, on trial in the United States court here on
charges of graft, was today acquitted.
Testimony given by Dr. Friedman and J[S.]. G. Nori, an Indian, a clerk
at the school during the trial was conflicting. Nori pleaded guilty to
embezzlement and the destruction of certain documents, at the instance
of Dr. Friedman. The court drew from Nori the statement that Friedman,
could have just as easily destroyed the papers himself, for he had access
to the safe, however he chose Nori to get rid of them, according to the
witness. On the stand, Dr. Friedman strongly denied the charges and gave
a detailed account of the duties of his office, stating that a number of
times he had refused to sign vouchers drawn up by Nori until they were
carefully checked. Nori, it developed, is separated from his wife and was
sentenced by a court some time ago to pay her for the support of her and
her two children.
************************************************************************
Adams County News (Gettysburg, Pennsylvania) October 23, 1915 [ancestry.com,
historical newspapers]
Clean Slate for Moses Friedman
Former Indian School Superintendent is Entirely Vindicated. Now Holds
Another Position at Salary of $3000.
The only untried indictment against M. Friedman, former superintendent
of the Carlisle Indian School, has been dismissed in the Federal District
Court of Central Pennsylvania. This indictment was for conspiracy. The
action was taken at the request of the U. S. Department of Justice and
with the approval of Federal Judge Witmer.
Dr. Friedman was acquitted and completely vindicated of the charges
brought against him by a prompt decision of the jury at the June session
of the Federal Court at Williamsport. Chief clerk Nori, who testified against
him at the trial was sent to the penitentiary.
A number of prominent men received letters and personal calls from
certain individuals attacking Dr. Friedman. They advised him of the contents
of the letters and the details of the visits made to harm him and take
from his their support. These influential men have continually advised
him to enter suit for libel in order to deter their further malicious attacks
on him and his family.
It is know that Dr. Friedman's counsel has under consideration the
prosecution of certain persons for libel and defamation of character. He
has suffered much during the past two years from malicious attacks by irresponsible
persons who have carried on an unscrupulous campaign through the mails
and newspapers to defame his name and character
Dr. Friedman has just been appointed to a most responsible position,
with a salary of $3,000 per year and all expenses.